There are 27,386 books about the 9/11 attack currently being sold on Amazon.
The authors of 27,385 of them are still alive, or dead from natural causes.
That leaves Philip Marshall, author of a self-published book about 9/11 called “The Big Bamboozle.”
In a small town in Northern California earlier this month, Marshall, a 56-year old ex-airline pilot, murdered his two children, Alex and Macaila, in their sleep, and then took his own life.
“A Murphy’s man killed his two children with a Glock 9mm handgun before turning the weapon on himself at his home in Forest Meadows late last week,” reported the local newspaper.
When deputies arrived, the paper reported, they found the children dead, lying on the couch with gunshot wounds, along with a dog that belonged to Marshall’s estranged wife.
“Former airline captain Philip Marshall, 54, killed his son Alex, 17, and daughter Macaila, 14, each with a single bullet to the head, as they slept nestled under blankets on the living room couch. He then pointed the gun at his head and committed suicide.”
That’s what happened…at least if you believe the police.
Human tragedy…or sinister black op?
But there are others today encouraging the notion that the Marshall family tragedy was, instead, a sinister government ‘black op.’
Marshall, these people say, was in possession of secret knowledge about the 9/11 attack, which he was about to reveal to a waiting world.
In “The Big Bamboozle” Marshall 'reveals' that “the sad truth is that all of the solid evidence points to a dark collaboration between members of the Bush Administration and a covert group of Saudi government officials.”
Wow. Fasten your seatbelts. The only big shocker is that Philip Marshall appears to be the last person to discern Saudi influence behind the 9/11 attack. It’s not even front page news. And its certainly nothing to kill him over.
If it were, there would be at least 15,000 authors, Madsen and myself among them, already dead.
But those selling the notion that Marshall was murdered ignore his book, so embarrassingly obscure that few knew of its existence before his death.
Instead they cite the brief relationship Marshall had over 30 years ago with Barry Seal, a life-long CIA pilot whose cocaine smuggling in military C123 military cargo planes funded the Contra’s war in Nicaragua and fueled the cocaine epidemic of the 1980’s.
Marshall himself used this brief association, in his author’s bio on Amazon, to spin a tale of nearly life-long derring-do.
But while this may be understandable hyperbole by an author hoping to hype his book, its embarrassingly thin gruel as support for an allegation of a government murder and cover-up.
A bad attitude can sometimes be a good thing
And this is where I entered the picture, after receiving several dozen increasingly frantic emails from people who knew of my book about Barry Seal, wondering what I knew, and what I was going to do, about this unspeakable government crime.
Asked one, “Are you following the Phillip Marshall thing?”
I replied, “Nope. Looks like suicide to me.”
At that, my correspondent got a little snarky with me, which is okay; I can—and sometimes do—get snarky with the best of them. “Well I guess this guy from the NSA doesn't know what he's talking about,” he sneered.
One the creepiest things about the community of people who find themselves dissatisfied with the lies they hear from the government is that these same people, who pride themselves on being the sort you can’t pull the wool over, no matter what, are as reliant on authority figures as the “sheeple” they bemoan.
The only thing about Philip Marshall’s death that is even potentially extraordinary is that he had a brief brush with the dark side of the force half-a-lifetime ago. Some apparently think this somehow gave him the keys to the hidden vault of secrets.
Similarly, reporter Wayne Madsen, because of former employment at the NSA, must perforce be privy to secret knowledge mere mortals of the non-spook variety will never understand. Madsen himself, who I consider a friend, would be the first to deny this.
Even well-respected author Anthony Summers, about whom I have not yet written (waiting for the bile to subside first) kept looking to his "sources" in the CIA and FBI to validate eyewitness testimony from creditable eyewitnesses on the ground in Venice Florida.
He was waiting for some authority figure to give him the shot.
The result was that when his tome on 9/11 was released, the only shocking new finding he could point to hadn't even made it into the book.
I was soon to learn that there is nothing but Marshall’s long-ago association with Barry Seal on which to base allegations of government assassination. This is evidenced by the fact that the name of Barry Seal, a man dead for more than 30 years, recurs almost more often in stories of Marshall’s death than does his own.
The hall of (very smudged-up) mirrors
So: here is where we enter the funhouse. But before we do, let’s consider what is at stake.
This is, after all, America, the country which is home to more REAL conspiracies than exist in all of the rest of the world combined.
So one must feel somewhat conflicted when forced to choose between these two views of the Marshall family tragedy: it was “A black ops hit made to appear as a suicide,” as a headline for one of Madsen’s articles has it.
Or…well, let’s let someone who was there, Kevin Raggi, the Coroner in Calaveras County (made famous by Mark Twain’s short story “The Jumping Frogs of Calaveras County”) describe the other way of viewing the crime.
Raggi told local reporters that it was one of the most heartbreaking scenes he’d ever seen, adding “Everyone was having a hard time.”
“You walk in there and you lose your breath and want to walk out and start crying,” he said. “It was heartbreaking. It’s incomprehensible.”
Was it just another unspeakable human tragedy, in a time, and a country, where such things have become all too common? Or was it a fiendish government black op designed to keep ‘we the people’ from ever learning the truth?
"Going back to school"
I was pointed to a transcript of a radio interview of Madsen conducted by Kevin Barrett, a self-styled "American Jihadist."
Read a typical comment left on Jarret’s website after Madsen's interview, "Speaking of “government” (i.e. Bolshevik Jewish) treachery, I’m sure most readers here have by now heard of (and/or seen) the so-called “No More Hesitation” targets being offered to “law enforcement” agencies by (and I’m going to out on a limb here and speculate) some Jew-owned company,”
“He was a former associate of the CIA/DEA informant Barry Seal, the notorious CIA cocaine smuggler,” opined Jarrett on the show. “And if you think Phillip Marshall killed himself and his two children as the police are trying to claim; well, I don’t know…you need to go back to school.”
His guest, Wayne Madsen, is a (usually) more creditable source.
“Well Phillip Marshall, I have to admit,” Madsen tells Jarrett, “I wasn’t all that familiar with his work. But when I read his biography along with the…some really scurrilous news reports that, ‘yknow, he was this, ‘yknow, this repressed killer who snapped, and put a gun on the head of his 17 year old son and his 14 year old daughter, and his little pet Shih Tzu, Suki, y’know, you start to wonder what in the world is going on here.”
The implication that there is something unusual about a “repressed killer who snapped and put a gun to the head of his 17-tear old son and 14-tear old daughter" seems a little…unusual.
"Dad kills kids & self"
Here’s a quick investigation that you can perform right at home: Google "dad kills kids and self."
Then read (if you have the stomach for it) all 84 million hits. I sifted through a few:
Husband of missing Utah mom kills sons, self;
Dad kills wife & kids, then himself over Obama's re-election
Father killed his two children and then himself after family split
DA: Mass. dad shoots 2 kids, 1 fatally, kills self
Quebec Father Kills Children & Self — Burns Garage
Herndon father shot wife, children before killing himself
Father kills his two children then himself on trip to Grand Canyon
I stopped after reading a deeply disturbing story out of Boynton Beach Florida, where a father killed his two sons as their mother begged for their lives. Then, after telling her he’d let her live so that she could suffer forever, he shot himself.
A verifiable fact amidst a the heavy breathing
By itself this isn’t proof that Marshall wasn’t killed by the government. But added to the fact that, of the 27,000 books on 9/11, all but Marshall are sleeping peacefully at night sets the bar pretty high for anyone seeking to prove he was murdered.
A bar the self-promoting nay-sayers apparently don’t even know exists.
Consider the one verifiable fact amidst all the heavy breathing abiut a government black op, Marshall’s association with Barry Seal.
Here’s what happened:
Seal’s pilot’s license had been suspended while he awaited trial in Miami. He engaged Marshall to fly him back and forth between there and his home in Baton Rouge.
The much-older Seal did have one protégé who was Marshall’s age, a man I found and interviewed for Barry & 'the boys.' Of the dozens of close Seal associates I interviewed, not one ever mentioned Philip Marshall.
In fairness, the world of aviation in Louisiana, which I wrote about in a book about Barry Seal called “Barry & the boys,’ can best be described as “murky.”
At last, a real eyewitness
But someone who knew Marshall at this time, his ex-wife, Ann Kallauner, a nurse in Louisiana, offered some clarity. Kallauner was wed to Marshall in 1985 (exactly the time frame when Marshall knew Seal.)
She told the local Union Democrat that her ex-husband “provided a kind of taxi service for Barry Seal, who the paper (inaccurately) reported “was assassinated by a trio of Medellin Cartel henchmen from Colombia.”
Kallauner said Marshall met Seal through “a friend of a friend” while teaching other pilots to fly from Lakefront Airport in New Orleans.
After Seal had his pilot’s license revoked, he hired Marshall to fly with him between New Orleans and Miami or Fort Lauderdale.
Seal often flew while Marshall remained in the jump seat, but Marshall never went with him into Nicaragua, she said.
“He wasn’t any Contra pilot,” said Kallauner. “That was all just a fantasy.”
A close associate of Seal’s, who asked to remain nameless, confirmed to me that her recollections were correct.
Kallauner also recited a litany of characteristics, also voiced to reporters by those who knew him at the time of his death, that have become well-known as markers in this all-too-common type of crime.
Marshall had problems with alcohol, was attention-seeking, egotistical, could be mean, and had a temper. He was nearly fired after yelling at a superior at Eastern Air Lines. He would throw clubs in the water while golfing.
“He had a problem with authority figures in his life,” she said. “One time he wanted me to roll down the (car) window to yell at a police officer.”
When she refused, she recalled, “He kind of got mad and smacked me back against the seat.”
Could someone have “gotten” to the ex-wife? Well, sure.
Could they also have gotten to the current friends of Marshall’s, who—to avoid speaking poorly of the dead—have only delicately raised questions of Marshall’s mental health at the time of his death?
Well, sure. But the only real question is: DID they? In the absence of compelling evidence to question their motives, the answer is simple. No, they did not. And here is where the disservice to the truth by attention-seekers and their deluded and credulous followers becomes most apparent.
People who see conspiracies where none exist render ridiculous-by-association people questioning the multitude of conspiracies that do.
More importantly, this is not the way things work in the real world.
How things work in the real world
America have not been kind to its real investigative journalists in recent years.
As a reporter for the Associated Press (but not for long), Robert Parry was the first to report on what came to be known as Iran Contra.
Pete Brewton did ground-breaking reporting at the Houston Post on the S & L scandal (The Mafia, CIA and George Bush” (1992) that led to his being shown the door.
And Gary Webb, who broke the story of CIA drug trafficking into the open, was summarily ushered out of newspaper reporting forever.
Webb represented a far greater threat to the powers that be than Phil Marshall ever could, even in his wildest dreams. But Webb wasn't murdered.
Gary Webb committed suicide on the day he lost his home. He'd already lost almost everything else: his family, his wife, his livelihood. An authentic American hero, Gary Webb was going to be moving home to live with his Mom.
He'd already asked his ex-girlfriend if he could share her apartment. At first she had said yes, but then changed her mind at the last minute, not wanting to lead him on in the hope that they'd rekindle a romance. Desperate, Webb asked his ex-wife if he could live with her until he regained his financial footing. She, too, refused.
Into the buzzsaw
On the night before losing his house, Webb lost his last real possession. His motorcycle was stolen.
He committed suicide the next day. And despite the nattering of clueless conspiracy theorists, I never doubted that that was exactly what happened. And I have since had nothing but contempt for those who claim otherwise.
I'd been there. I'd spent a year living in motels after my first full-length documentary, "The Secret Heartbeat of America," failed to sell to television. I persisted. When Barry & the boys' was published, a lawsuit by one of Barry Seal's closest long-time associates kept the book out of bookstores for almost five years.
Again, I persisted. But I'd never tell anyone it was anything but a soul-killing dispiriting experience. It's an experience better people than me have faced again and again.
Telling the truth in America often feels like walking "Into The Buzzsaw," the title of a very good book about journalists exiled to the American gulag, a Siberia of the mind where nothing you do or report subsequently is ever treated seriously.
Expose anything this country's large institutions want kept under wraps… and the buzzsaw rips through you.
Because they don't have to kill you to render you ineffective.
For the oligarchy ruling this country today, that part is easy.
I do find it strange that Hopsicker does not mention that Gary Webb was killed with 2 bullets to the head which might be why many people wonder. The people he made angry with his reporting are violent vindictive sucks who hold grudges for a long time. I mean, there is still an American embargo on Cuba since the 60s. Suicide is not very inspiring which kind of lowers his reputation quite a bit. Then again it does sound like he was depressed. Moving back to your mother’s house at 49 is not the tale of a happy camper. He should have found the right shaman.
“People who see conspiracies where none exist render ridiculous-by-association people questioning the multitude of conspiracies that do.” Well said.
You seem to have a typo in the name Barrett in your story, and also the wrong photo for Kevin Barrett. You refer to him as “Jarrett.”
Man… everything is posted out of order here. Hall of mirrors? Man, you got that right.
Anyway as of March 1, (which was today when I wrote) it appears that Santa Barbara View has got some updates which correct a few of my own misconceptions, which I won’t enumerate.
http://www.santabarbaraview.com/mystery-still-shrouds-triple-shooting-deaths-in-gold-country5365363/
“Why does it have to have anything to do with 9/11?” Because otherwise this guy is just another lame asshole who killed his kids. That he wasn’t worth murdering because of what he knew about 9/11 is the point.
@[1067427484:2048:Jane Clark] damn. i am supremely unconcerned about my “credibility” with you–or anyone else. within two minutes of replying to the rude accusation which prompted it, i deleted the accusation and my response, only to be alerted by YOUR comment that both were still here. in fact, i find i’m unable for some reason to delete your friends comment, and only able to partially amend my own. i expect life will go on.
gg
Daniel Hopsicker — Why does it have to have anything to do with 9/11? It would seem to me that your entire argument is that he was a nobody and that he wasn’t worth murdering for what he knew about 9/11. Mocking people while declaring QED over a piss poor biased rant is beneath your talent.
In the Bamboozle Marshall does not brag about or try to overdo his involvement with Barry Seal, only presents it as a point of departure for his interest.
As for Marshall knowing zip about 9/11 or not, well his research is ok. He dismisses out of hand controlled demolition etc. but this seems to be because he has done as Michael Ruppert and concentrates on what people did and avoids physical/scientific evidence.
And knowing about 9/11? anyone can research it for a few days and safely conclude that the thing was a fraud and served as pretext to launch various plans that had been laid long before but needed this crisis to get going.
But people are mesmerized by the media machine.
Good article – I have read Marshall’s book and it seems a good supplement to Michael Ruppert’s effort, but hard to read, you really have to be interested. Good piece of research though. But it does not seem to give motive for a black op or murder. And something he said (bragged) about great things in next book is not much to go on.
There are definitely oddities in the case. It does not seem that Marshall was particularly down and out. He had money, house and had settled down to research and write. Would he kill himself and these beautiful almost grown up children over his marriage problems? How long had they been separated, wasn’t it some time?
Heartbreaking indeed.
I like the way you end the piece comparing yourself to these losers, Webb and Marshall 😉
(In the Bamboozle Marshall points out as odd/impossible that Webb would shoot himself twice in the head, maybe some black opper read that and got an idea?)
The government cannot be trusted. Our rulers are our elected officials and their killbots enforce their rules. Sample of a killbot’s mindset: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YvmDdVoroI0.